19. Dr. Bird's Advice for Sad Poets


There's no other way around this...this book just made me sad. It was the very opposite of uplifting; instead of giving hope to those who suffer from apathy or depression, it seemed to highlight the very worst of the disease while offering no relief. Alright, so the ending was somewhat hopeful, but it wasn't cheerful enough for me. I felt that the entire story had a downcast undertone and it was not a happy summer story.


Boring. Boring, boring, boring. I feel terrible about having no empathy for the main character, who is depressed and suicidal and just overall miserable. But he is a flat character with little to no personality. His disease seems to define him in this story, along with his obsession with saving his sister, who was kicked out of the house. Ironically, he seems outraged on her behalf, but even though he is abused by his parents as well, it doesn’t occur to him to get help. He merely spends his time obsessing over a girl who already has a boyfriend. It’s cringe-worthy. Plus, the writing style is amateurish. While the author may have been aiming to mimic the thought process of teenagers, he fell short with his fragmented sentences and excessive exclamation points. Even worse are the side characters. The protagonist’s sister was kicked out of school and there is originally a sense of mystery around it. The author sets it up to seem like a larger conspiracy, only for the reader to find out that there was no bigger story. It was disappointing. There was potential for the story to improve with the introduction of Dr. Bird, an imaginary psychiatrist. However, the bird does very little and doesn’t seem to matter much in the bigger picture. I just kept having my hopes raised every once in a while, only for them to be dashed. Maybe I prefer stories with happy endings, and the slightly optimistic ending here wasn’t good enough for me. Either way, I found the story to be the very opposite of uplifting, and not a worthwhile read.

No comments:

Post a Comment